Kevin O'Toole News: Back for 2026

O'Toole will remain in New York after his contract has been exercised for the 2026 season.

O'Toole completed his fourth season in New York and will enter his fifth year in the city. He had a minor stint on the injured list, missing May with a knee injury. However, the defender bounced back, maintaining his starting role at left back, recording a goal and an assist in 31 appearances (including the playoffs). O'Toole will be back as a top option in the back line for the team in 2026, barring any injuries.