2020 NFL Team Previews: Indianapolis Colts

2020 NFL Team Previews: Indianapolis Colts

This article is part of our Team Previews series.

Indianapolis Colts

With a promising young defense and stout offensive line, the Colts entered last season with high hopes, but the team also was compensating for the sudden departure of Andrew Luck. Signing Philip Rivers should improve the team's quarterback production, especially with additional skill-position weapons added this offseason.

Offseason Moves

Key Acquisitions

Indy turns to the 38-year-old to boost its QB play.

Cost the team a first-round pick, but he's a star interior lineman.

The prolific college runner will split time in the backfield with Marlon Mack.

A big-bodied possession target to complement the team's speedy wideouts.

An injury bounce-back candidate who'll provide depth behind Jack Doyle.

Key Losses

A much younger name will look to replace the accomplished kicker.

Departs Indy after just one season lost to injury.

The key red-zone target moves on to Pittsburgh.

A Look Under the Hood

Head Coach: Frank Reich (Year 3)

Offensive Coordinator: Nick Sirianni (Year 3) - West Coast Offense

Defensive Coordinator: Matt Eberflus (Year 3) - 4-3 scheme

2020 Vegas Projected Wins: 8.5 (T-14th)


2019 Record: 7-9

2019 Points Scored: 361 (T-16th)

2019 Points Allowed: 373 (18th)

2019 Point Differential: -12 (17th)

2019 Run-Play Rate: 46.4 percent (5th)

2019 Situation-Neutral Pace: 31.79 seconds per play (25th)

2019 Offensive Snaps: 1,016 (18th)

2019 PFF O-Line Ranking: No. 3

Full 2019 Team Stats


Projected 2020 Depth Chart

QB: Philip Rivers / Jacoby Brissett / Jacob Eason

RB: Marlon Mack / Jonathan Taylor / Nyheim Hines / Jordan Wilkins

WR1: T.Y. Hilton / Marcus Johnson / Dezmon Patmon

WR2: Michael Pittman / Zach Pascal

WR3: Parris Campbell / Daurice Fountain

TE: Jack Doyle / Trey Burton / Mo Alie-Cox

O-Line: LT Anthony Castonzo / LG Quenton Nelson / C Ryan Kelly / RG Mark Glowinski / RT Braden Smith                   (RotoWire Rank: No. 1)

Kicker: Chase McLaughlin / Rodrigo Blankenship

Full 2020 Depth Chart

Top Storylines

Can Philip Rivers Revive the Passing Attack?

The Colts approached the 2019 campaign with one of the most envious signal-caller situations in the league, but Andrew Luck shockingly retired at age 28 just days before the season opener. The team turned to backup Jacoby Brissett, but the results were disappointing.

As a result, the team signed Philip Rivers, who departs the Chargers after starting all of the franchise's games for the past 14 seasons. While he's coming off what was arguably the poorest effort of his career, exemplified by a 23:20 TD:INT, Rivers still logged 7.8 YPA and a 66.0 completion percentage, with both marks easily topping Brissett's (6.6 and 60.9, respectively).

Now reunited with Frank Reich, who served as the Chargers offensive coordinator during some of the QB's peak years, Rivers has a plethora of weapons in the passing game. T.Y. Hilton – who missed six games last season with quad and calf injuries – is back as the team's top wideout. Hilton's return to health will be key, as his ability to stretch defenses opens up the Indy attack. 

Meanwhile, third-year man Zach Pascal will face competition from a pair of promising second-round picks in Parris Campbell (2019) and Michael Pittman (2020). Additionally, Rivers will be throwing to reliable tight end Jack Doyle and newcomer Trey Burton, all while working behind one of the league's best offensive lines.

Running Back by Committee?

With Marlon Mack coming off his first 1,000-yard season, the Colts surprised many by selecting Jonathan Taylor in the second round of April's draft. Of course, he was the second player in FBS history to post consecutive 2,000-yard rushing seasons and the second to win consecutive Doak Walker awards.

Running a 4.39 40 at the combine at a rock-solid 226 pounds, Taylor profiles as a player who can bowl over defenders while also providing a home-run threat. He carries question marks as a receiver and ball security concerns, however. Taylor recorded just 42 catches in three college seasons with Wisconsin and racked up 18 fumbles on 968 touches, along with several high-profile drops in that span.

Mack began last season with a bang, piling up 174 rushing yards against the Chargers in Week 1, but that proved to be the high-water mark of his season as a potential breakout campaign turned into a merely good one. Mack used his elusiveness to post four games of 95 yards or more, and he had nine runs of over 20 yards. However, he wasn't used much in the passing game, with just 14 receptions.

Mack and Taylor would appear to have similar skill sets, but offensive coordinator Nick Sirianni called them a 1-1 punch in the spring and plans to split the workload. It's unclear how much either will be used in the passing game, however, with Nyheim Hines seemingly entrenched as the team's change-of-pace back. The usage pattern of the Indy backfield could be frustrating for fantasy owners as a result.

Early down work in Indy will be of interest as Marlon Mack looks to fend off Jonathan Taylor.

Can the Defense Be Elite?

The Colts defense took a slight step back last season as it ranked 18th in points allowed and 16th in yards surrendered. While the defense was stout against the run – seventh in yards allowed, 11th in net yards per attempt – it struggled against the pass (23rd in pass yards allowed, 22nd in net yards per attempt).

The Colts allowed the league's second-highest completion percentage (75.4), according to Pro Football Focus. This offseason, the team made a bold move, dealing a first-rounder for DeForest Buckner, one of the league's top interior lineman. Buckner's presence will make it a challenge for opposing offenses to contain both him and defensive end Justin Houston (11 sacks last season).

An improved pass rush will help a secondary that will have some turnover. Starting cornerback Pierre Desir left in free agency and backup Quincy Wilson was traded to the Jets. To boost the unit, the Colts signed Xavier Rhodes in free agency. Rhodes was once one of the top cover corners in the league, but his performance declined over the past two seasons.

Questions persist regarding the performance and health of Malik Hooker, as the team decided not to pick up his fifth-year option. The emergence of cornerback Rock Ya-Sin and safety Khari Willis as rookie starters could lift the unit in their respective second years. Moreover, Kenny Moore was a dominant defender by allowing just 5.9 yards per target and just one touchdown in pass coverage in 2019.

If the secondary can improve, the defense has a chance to be elite, with stars at linebacker in Darius Leonard and Anthony Walker on hand.


⬆️ Rising: WR Michael Pittman

At 6-4, 223, Pittman has fast-for-his-size speed (4.52 40-yard dash). He should be a nice complement to No. 1 wideout T.Y. Hilton and speedy second-year player Parris Campbell and could quickly emerge as a starter.

⬇️ Falling: RB Marlon Mack

Last season's "main guy" in the backfield now has to share top billing with second-round pick Jonathan Taylor and will cede passing-down work to Nyheim Hines.

😴 Sleeper: WR Parris Campbell

He's coming off an injury-plagued rookie season, but Campbell has the speed (4.31-second 40) and athleticism to thrive in the slot and emerge as a key target for QB Philip Rivers

🌟 Pivotal Player: Philip Rivers

The Indianapolis offense has an abundance of weapons and a premier line, but the team needs improved quarterback play to make the playoffs. Can a 17-year veteran coming off one of his worst seasons be the answer? Rivers' record of durability and consistently strong YPA numbers provide hope.

RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
Peter Schoenke
Peter Schoenke is the president and co-founder of RotoWire.com. He's been elected to the hall of fame for both the Fantasy Sports Trade Association and Fantasy Sports Writers Association and also won the Best Fantasy Baseball Article on the Internet in 2005 from the FSWA. He roots for for the Minnesota Twins, Vikings and T-Wolves.
NFL Reactions: The Sunday Before the Super Bowl
NFL Reactions: The Sunday Before the Super Bowl
Best Ball Journal: Underdog 2023 Rookies
Best Ball Journal: Underdog 2023 Rookies
Early Look At Best Super Bowl LVII Prop Picks: First Touchdown Scored
Early Look At Best Super Bowl LVII Prop Picks: First Touchdown Scored
SXM Highlights: Did Denver Get Desperate?
SXM Highlights: Did Denver Get Desperate?
Will Bill O’Brien Help The Patriots Super Bowl Odds In 2023?
Will Bill O’Brien Help The Patriots Super Bowl Odds In 2023?
What Offseason Changes Will Mean For 2023 Patriots Super Bowl Odds
What Offseason Changes Will Mean For 2023 Patriots Super Bowl Odds