Beating the Book: NFL Week 1 Odds & Picks

Beating the Book: NFL Week 1 Odds & Picks

This article is part of our Beating the Book series.

Week 1 of the NFL season is nearly upon us, but more importantly it brings with it the start of fantasy football leagues, survivor pools and, of course, good old fashioned betting against the spread each week.

While I also co-host RotoWire Fantasy Sports Today with Jeff Erickson (8-10 p.m. EDT on Sirius XM's Fantasy Sports channel), as well as a handful of RotoWire podcasts, my goal in this space is to help you sort through the lines, offer my two cents, and in the end help you make the most sensible bets on weekly basis.

Looking at Week 1 specifically, we're presented with a unique slate featuring 10 road favorites. There are never any gimmes in Week 1, but that's especially true this season. Virtually every matchup that appears lopsided on paper pits the better team — the Ravens, Colts, Saints, Broncos and Saints, for instance — on the road. The two exceptions are the Steelers-Bengals and Giants-Titans matchups. As of Wednesday morning, Cincinnati is a 6.5-point home favorite, while the Titans sit at -6.0, per BetMGM.

As will be the case every week throughout the regular season, we'll start with Thursday Night Football and go game-by-game, picking each contest against the spread. My best bet will always be highlighted in gold. All odds this week come via BetMGM.

NFL Week 1 Odds: Bills, Eagles among 10 road favorites

Use the BetMGM Bonus Code for a risk-free bet up to $1,000.

NFL Week 1 Picks

Thursday Night Opener

Buffalo Bills (-2.5) at Los Angeles Rams

As has typically been the case since the NFL began placing the defending champions in the Thursday opener, this is a true banger of a matchup. The Rams are undefeated in season openers in the Sean McVay era, while the Bills enter the year as the it team and the Super Bowl favorites.

The line has come a long way since it opened at Rams -1.0 in May. The last four months, Buffalo has only picked up steam, while there seems to be some healthy skepticism around the Rams — in particular the health of Matthew Stafford's elbow.

While history may be on the Rams' side — defending Super Bowl champs are 14-2 at home in these openers since 2004 – I'm rolling with Buffalo as a more of a vote of confidence in Josh Allen and this roster than an indictment on Stafford and the Rams.

The pick: Bills 31 – Rams 24

Sunday Early Games

New Orleans Saints (-5.5) at Atlanta Falcons

With Sean Payton gone, the Saints face more questions than ever this season, but they get a favorable, in-division matchup to begin the schedule. And keep in mind that last season they blew the doors off of the Packers in Week 1 as 3.5-point dogs.

I'm not expecting big things in Michael Thomas' first game since January 2021, but the Saints have quality options behind him and, most important, a healthy Alvin Kamara. The Falcons' offense will be friskier than most expect, so I don't see this devolving into a total blowout, but I like the Saints to cover and move to 1-0 heading into next weekend's showdown against the Bucs.

The pick: Saints 27 – Falcons 17

San Francisco 49ers (-7.0) at Chicago Bears

Man-to-man, this matchup has the biggest gap in overall talent in Week 1. I'm on record that the Bears could finish with the league's worst record this season, so this line could easily be a point or two higher. However, the fact that it's holding at 7.0 is an indication that there's still a decent amount of wait-and-see factor when it comes to Trey Lance. In the long term, I love Lance's upside, but I'm willing to admit that it could be a bumpy ride early in the season.

I think we get a relatively low-scoring game that's ultimately controlled by San Francisco's defense. I see this one playing out similarly to last year's Week 17 matchup against the Texans, which Lance started in place of Jimmy Garoppolo.

The pick: 49ers 24 – Bears 10

Pittsburgh Steelers (+6.5) at Cincinnati Bengals

I love the Bengals as somewhat of a dark horse Super Bowl bet after nearly getting the job done last season. And while I think they escape with a win at home in Week 1, I don't see this being an easy victory. Starting Mitch Trubisky at quarterback may be Mike Tomlin's greatest challenge yet, but the Steelers are on the short list of teams that always find a way to keep games competitive.

The Bengals could give the home crowd a scare in the first half, but over 60 minutes their overwhelming talent at the skill positions — coupled with an improved offensive line — should barely win out.

The pick: Bengals 27 – Steelers 24

Philadelphia Eagles (-4.0) at Detroit Lions

It feels like everyone wants the Lions — the greatest three-win team in NFL history last season — to happen this season, but I think they're still another year away from making that leap. Defensively, I don't like their chances to slow the Eagles, who bulldozed Detroit for 236 rushing yards in last season's 44-6 beatdown.

Philadelphia still has one of the best offensive lines in the league and made a number of big-time additions, both through the draft and via trades, on both sides of the ball. I like Detroit's offense to find ways to move the ball, but it won't be enough to offset the defensive shortcomings.

The pick: Eagles 34 – Lions 24

New England Patriots (+3.5) at Miami Dolphins

The Patriots are coming in ice cold off of one of the worst preseason showings in recent memory. The question for me is do they still deserve the benefit of the doubt that inherently comes with a Bill Belichick-coached team? Remember, they started 1-3 last season before winning eight of their next nine.

I'm a card-carrying member of the Tua isn't that guy club, but it's tough to fade the Dolphins in Week 1, at home, against an opponent they always seem to play well (7-2 in last nine home games vs. NE). That said, it wouldn't be a shock if Mike McDaniel's offense takes a few games to fully click.

In the end, I don't think we come away from this game feeling great about either team, but I'll go with a near-repeat of last season's Week 1 matchup in Foxboro.

The pick: Dolphins 20 – Patriots 19

Baltimore Ravens (-7.0) at New York Jets

I love the Ravens in this matchup, and I'll love them even more if it's Zach Wilson under center for the Jets. Joe Flacco isn't exactly a daunting opponent in his own right, but it feels like there's just enough potential for the game to get weird if the 37-year-old, ex-Raven gets the nod.

Either way, I think the Ravens roll the Jets and John Harbaugh moves to 11-4 in season openers since taking over in 2008. Prior to last season's overtime loss to the Raiders, Baltimore had won its previous three openers by a combined 144-19.

The pick: Ravens 33 – Jets 14

Jacksonville Jaguars (+2.5) at Washington Commanders

In the interest of full disclosure I'm a Jaguars fan (long story), so I can assure you I've been subjected to about as much Jags football the last two decades as anyone living north of the Mason-Dixon. After last season's top-to-bottom embarrassment, there's plenty of reason for optimism, but I'm not sure this team really improved all that much from a personnel standpoint.

Conversely, from a pure competency and preparedness standpoint, Jacksonville should be much, much better. It can't be overstated how poorly this team was prepared on a week-to-week basis last season. But in terms of the roster, it felt like the Jags loaded up on a bunch of B-minus-level players in free agency. Overall, they'll be a more competitive team week-to-week, but I know better than to have high expectations to begin the year.

Reluctantly, give me Carson Wentz.

The pick: Commanders 26 – Jaguars 20

Cleveland Browns (+2.5) at Carolina Panthers

As you've likely heard by now, the Browns have not won a season-opener since 2004 — a completely preposterous streak. I realize what I'm getting myself into going against what feels like an inevitability at this point, but all streaks must end. And what better man to pull Browns fans out of their misery than the 2019 Week 7 AFC Offensive Player of the Week?

In all seriousness, Jacoby Brissett probably struggles to do much of anything in Week 1, but if the Browns simply lean on Nick Chubb and their offensive line, I like their chances to pull out the ugliest, I-can't-believe-I-just-watched-60-minutes-of-that win of Week 1. 

Of course, we have to acknowledge the Baker Mayfield revenge factor. Frankly, I'm not sure how to quantify it. All I know is it's beginning to feel like Mayfield is going to play either the best or the worst game of his entire football career.

I'm taking the Browns and assuming they get to 15 on points on five field goals — or maybe four safeties and a touchdown.

The pick: Browns 15 – Panthers 13

Indianapolis Colts (-7.0) at Houston Texans

I have plenty of questions about the Colts' overall ceiling, but in bringing in Matt Ryan they essentially secured the exact opposite of Carson Wentz. It's easy to forget that Wentz was sneakily effective early on last season, but Ryan is a major floor-raiser at the position who will help keep Indianapolis from some of last season's disaster games.

I may be slightly higher on the Texans than most, and I wouldn't be surprised if they hang around in this game for two or three quarters, but eventually the better team will win out. It's as simple as that.

The pick: Colts 26 – Texans 14

Sunday Late Games

New York Giants (+6.0) at Tennessee Titans

The last few seasons, the Titans have always found a way to exceed expectations. This will be Mike Vrabel's toughest test yet, but I think some are underrating just how impactful a healthy Derrick Henry will be. He'll need to prove he's back to his old self, physically, but if he is, that will go a long way toward offsetting the loss of A.J. Brown

In a low-scoring game, I trust the Titans' defense to consistently pressure Daniel Jones and limit Saquon Barkley to one of those 15-50-0 lines fantasy managers know all too well.

The pick: Titans 17 – Giants 10

Green Bay Packers (-1.5) at Minnesota Vikings

While the Packers avoid a complete no-show like last season's Week 1 blowout against New Orleans, there's reason to believe the offense could get off to a pedestrian start to the post-Davante Adams era. I still like Green Bay to once again find its way to 12 or 13 wins and another playoff run, but this is a difficult spot against what should be an improved Vikings offensive attack.

Unlike in years past, the Packers' talent-loaded defense does give me some pause. But in the end, I don't think Green Bay's receivers make quite enough plays to offset a productive debut for the Cousins-Cook-Jefferson trio under Kevin O'Connell. These teams have split their last four meetings and Green Bay holds only a narrow 8-7-1 edge since 2014.

The pick: Vikings 23 – Packers 20

Kansas City Chiefs (-6.0) at Arizona Cardinals

This line is on the move in favor of Kansas City since sitting at Chiefs -4.5 earlier in the week. Arizona has gotten off to hot starts in recent years, but that will be a difficult task against Patrick Mahomes and Co. — even if the "Co." no longer includes Tyreek Hill. If DeAndre Hopkins were on the field for Arizona, maybe you could talk me into an upset. But the Cards will be down their top receiver and could very well be without Zach Ertz, as well. 

Meanwhile, the Chiefs have questions at receiver, but I have too much faith in Mahomes and Andy Reid to believe they'll suffer a letdown in Week 1.

The pick: Chiefs 35 – Cardinals 23

Las Vegas Raiders (+3.5) at Los Angeles Chargers

After Jaguars-Commanders wraps up, this is the game everyone will be tracking closely in the late window. The Chargers come in with the most hype for a non-playoff team in NFL history, while the Raiders, with Davante Adams in the mix, are looking for a repeat of last year's Week 18 thriller.

Chaos always seems to follow the Chargers, regardless of coach or quarterback, so I'm trying to be wary of the possibility for some general absurdity in this game. Keep in mind that the Raiders took down the Ravens as home underdogs in Week 1 last season. And the Chargers could be missing one of their big offseason additions in J.C. Jackson. But for as much as I like what this Raiders offense can be, I can't talk myself out of backing Los Angeles to cover the 3.5. 

The pick: Chargers 31 – Raiders 27

Sunday Night Football

Tampa Bay Buccaneers (-2.5) at Dallas Cowboys

For as much as the Buccaneers' offensive line attrition concerns me, the Cowboys' line is in even worse shape. Dallas also lost a significant piece in Amari Cooper and will be without Michael Gallup to begin the year. CeeDee Lamb is a star and Dalton Schultz could be on his way to that status, but overall it feels like this is a decidedly worse Cowboys offensive unit than last season.

Again, the Bucs have some holes of their own, but for the most part they return the major pieces from a loaded 2021 team. If Chris Godwin is ultimately cleared for Week 1, I love the Bucs' chances to get off to a 1-0 start with a win over Dallas for the second consecutive year.

The pick: Buccaneers 29 – Cowboys 23

Monday Night Football

Denver Broncos (-6.5) at Seattle Seahawks

Unlike the Cleveland-Carolina game, this one is being played in the correct location. I'm having a difficult time figuring out just what kind of reception Russell Wilson will get in his return to Seattle. It won't be a LeBron-back-in-Cleveland or Favre-back-in-Green-Bay situation, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's a more hostile environment than most would expect. The man was boo'd at a Seattle Storm game last month.

On the field, I don't think Seattle will be a complete disaster. Hanging on to DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett, combined with 2021 late-season breakout Rashaad Penny, should be enough to keep the Seahawks out of the basement. I think they'll be able to run the ball against what was a middle-of-the-road run defense for Denver last season. But in the end, the gap in quarterback play will be too much for Seattle to overcome. 

The pick: Broncos 30 – Seahawks 17

RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Nick Whalen
Now in his 10th year with the company, Nick is RotoWire's Senior Media Analyst, a position he took on after several years as the Head of Basketball Content. A multi-time FSGA and FSWA award winner, Nick co-hosts RotoWire's flagship show on Sirius XM Fantasy alongside Jeff Erickson, as well as The RotoWire NBA Show on Sirius XM NBA with Alex Barutha. He also co-hosts RotoWire's Football and Basketball podcasts. You can catch Nick's NBA and NFL analysis on VSiN and DraftKings, as well as RotoWire's various social and video channels. Follow him on Twitter and Instagram @wha1en.
NFL Mock Draft: 2024 First-Round Mock
NFL Mock Draft: 2024 First-Round Mock
NFL Draft: Final Three-Round Mock
NFL Draft: Final Three-Round Mock
2024 NFL Draft: NFL Draft Props for the First Round
2024 NFL Draft: NFL Draft Props for the First Round
NFL Draft Props and Betting Odds: Where Will Jayden Daniels Land?
NFL Draft Props and Betting Odds: Where Will Jayden Daniels Land?
7 Rookies Smart Dynasty Fantasy Football Owners Are Drafting (Video)
7 Rookies Smart Dynasty Fantasy Football Owners Are Drafting (Video)
Ryan Grubb and the History of College Coaches Headed to the NFL
Ryan Grubb and the History of College Coaches Headed to the NFL