Milwaukee Brewers vs. St. Louis Cardinals & More MLB Best Bets, Expert Picks for May 9

Milwaukee Brewers vs. St. Louis Cardinals & More MLB Best Bets, Expert Picks for May 9

This article is part of our MLB Picks series.

MLB Bets Today: Expert MLB Picks for Thursday, May 9

Life has interfered with the start of the MLB season and has kept me from taking my regular weekly spot here, but I'm back for today and very happy to be so. The good news is I have fared well in my few appearances so far this year, posting a 5-3 record, good for +2 units. Today, I'm excited to have three plays that I see as quite strong in today's limited slate. Let's dive in! 

MLB fans: Get in on the action with the BetMGM bonus code for a first-bet bonus welcome offer worth up to $1,500 when using code ROTOBONUS. BetMGM is one of several leading sportsbooks that accept credit card and PayPal.

Seattle Mariners @ Minnesota Twins Best Bet

The thing that struck me about today's games overall is the strong career numbers posted by today's starting pitchers, many of whom have a good deal of experience against their opponents. With 36 and 51 ABs, respectively, Pablo Lopez and Logan Gilbert fit those descriptions. Both have fared quite well against each others' teams and the total of 6.5 reflects that. Winners of eight of 10, the Twins are hot, but Seattle can earn a road split with a win today. With their ace on the hill and these teams being evenly matched, we have to take the advantage of the value on the Mariners today. 

Baseball fans present in the Tar Heel State can claim thousands of dollars in bonuses with North Carolina betting promos this baseball season now that North Carolina sports betting is officially live. The Caesars Sportsbook North Carolina promo code gets new customers $250 in bonus bets after making an initial wager of at least $10.

MLB Pick for Mariners @ Twins

  • Mariners ML +114 (@ BetRivers)

Houston Astros @ New York Yankees Best Bet

Right now, if you aren't on the Yankees or the over in their games, there is an element of risk, particularly with games in the Bronx. However, like Austin Powers, Danger is my middle name. Actually, that isn't true ... Value is my middle name here, and that's what we find with the under in today's game. Yankees starter Marcus Stroman has dominated the current Astros bats over his career while Houston counters with the lone bright spot in their rotation, Ronel Blanco. Blanco has not faced this lineup yet, but has taken on Toronto and Texas (twice). This is a classic getaway game as both teams travel to start road weekend series. These are games I love to target for unders as both teams are motivated to work fast and save guys for the road trip. Here's a rare, tidy 3-2 pitcher's duel in the Bronx today. 

MLB Pick for Astros @ Yankees

  • HOU/NYY UNDER 8.5 +115 (@ BetMGM)

Milwaukee Brewers vs. St. Louis Cardinals Best Bet

To me, this is a classic line that overvalues a known pitcher against a relative unknown. While it is true that the Brewers are in a bit of a funk and Sonny Gray is red-hot, but from top to bottom, the Brewers are the superior team overall and are playing at home. The Brewers have owned the Cards over the last few years and the start of a four-game series against a bitter rival should get them jump started. There is too much value on the Brewers to ignore today. 

MLB Picks for Brewers vs. Cardinals

  • Brewers ML +114 (@ DraftKings)

MLB Best Bets Recap for Thursday, May 9

  • SEA ML +114 (@ BetRivers)
  • HOU/NYY UNDER 8.5 +115 (@ BetMGM)
  • MIL ML +115 (@ DraftKings)

RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Eric  Timm
Eric is celebrating his 22nd season as a featured handicapper with Nelly's Sportsline! He specializes in the NFL, College Football, College Basketball, and MLB. His positive demeanor coupled with a steady and measured approach has helped his clients attain both short and long-term success, making him one of the most respected handicappers in the Midwest.
Farm Futures: Holiday Prospect Mailbag!
Farm Futures: Holiday Prospect Mailbag!
Collette Calls: 2025 AL East Bold Predictions
Collette Calls: 2025 AL East Bold Predictions
Offseason Deep Dives: Jack Flaherty
Offseason Deep Dives: Jack Flaherty
MLB: Winter Meetings Recap
MLB: Winter Meetings Recap
Offseason Deep Dives: Garrett Crochet
Offseason Deep Dives: Garrett Crochet
Farm Futures: Rookie Infielder Targets
Farm Futures: Rookie Infielder Targets