Points were assigned to each player based on their ranking by each writer: 20 points for a first place vote, 19 points for a second place vote, 18 points for a third place vote and so on.
We had no consensus top picks at any position, which just goes to show how weird of a Premier League season it's been so far. Our preseason list included unanimous top-choices of Robin van Persie at forward and Gareth Bale, who ended up not playing a single Premier League game this season before his move to Real Madrid, at midfield. Needless to say, it was time for an update.
Rankings last updated 10/23
| FORWARDS | MIDFIELDERS | DEFENDERS | GOALKEEPERS | |
| 1 | Olivier Giroud | Mesut Ozil | Leighton Baines | Simon Mignolet |
| 2 | Romelu Lukaku | Oscar | Branislav Ivanovic | Petr Cech |
| 3 | Christan Benteke | Yaya Toure | Pablo Zabaleta | Hugo Lloris |
| 4 | Daniel Sturridge | Aaron Ramsey | Jan Vertonghen | Artur Boruc |
| 5 | Luis Suarez | Michu | Kyle Walker | Joe Hart |
| 6 | Robin van Persie | Eden Hazard | Seamus Coleman | Wojciech Szczesny |
| 7 | Sergio Aguero | Paulinho | David Luiz | Asmir Begovic |
| 8 | Wayne Rooney | Steven Gerrard | Glen Johnson | David de Gea |
| 9 | Loic Remy | David Silva | Patrice Evra | Tim Howard |
| 10 | Roberto Soldado | Andros Townsend | John Terry | Jussi Jaaskelainen |
| 11 | Alvaro Negredo | Frank Lampard | Jose Enrique | |
| 12 | Wilfried Bony | Ross Barkley | Dejan Lovren | |
| 13 | Rickie Lambert | Hatem Ben Arfa | Jose Fonte | |
| 14 | Gabriel Agbonlahor | Santi Cazorla | Danny Rose | |
| 15 | Samuel Eto'o | Theo Walcott | Per Mertesacker | |
| 16 | Edin Dzeko | Marouane Fellaini | Daniel Agger | |
| 17 | Fernando Torres | Emanuele Giaccherini | Curtis Davies | |
| 18 | Darren Bent | Adnan Januzaj | Phil Jagielka | |
| 19 | Danny Welbeck | Morgan Amalfitano | Kieran Gibbs | |
| 20 | Fraizer Campbell | Ravel Morrison | Sylvan Distin |
FORWARDS
QUICK LINKS
| # | OVERALL | PTS | LAIRD | MOSINSKI | PITNER | RADUNE |
| 1 | Olivier Giroud | 75 | Christian Benteke | Olivier Giroud | Luis Suarez | Romelu Lukaku |
| 2 | Romelu Lukaku | 73 | Luis Suarez | Luis Suarez | Olivier Giroud | Olivier Giroud |
| 3 | Christian Benteke | 71 | Romelu Lukaku | Romelu Lukaku | Sergio Aguero | Christian Benteke |
| 4 | Daniel Sturridge | 60 | Olivier Giroud | Christian Benteke | Romelu Lukaku | Robin van Persie |
| 5 | Luis Suarez | 59 | Daniel Sturridge | Wayne Rooney | Christian Benteke | Edin Dzeko |
| 6 | Robin van Persie | 58 | Sergio Aguero | Daniel Sturridge | Daniel Sturridge | Wayne Rooney |
| 7 | Sergio Aguero | 57 | Robin van Persie | Sergio Aguero | Robin van Persie | Daniel Sturridge |
| 8 | Wayne Rooney | 55 | Roberto Soldado | Robin van Persie | Wayne Rooney | Loic Remy |
| 9 | Loic Remy | 45 | Alvaro Negredo | Loic Remy | Alvaro Negredo | Gabriel Agbonlahor |
| 10 | Roberto Soldado | 42 | Wayne Rooney | Roberto Soldado | Loic Remy | Danny Welbeck |
| 11 | Alvaro Negredo | 40 | Wilfried Bony | Wilfried Bony | Roberto Soldado | Sergio Aguero |
| 12 | Wilfried Bony | 33 | Loic Remy | Rickie Lambert | Samuel Eto'o | Alvaro Negredo |
| 13 | Rickie Lambert | 27 | Fernando Torres | Fernando Torres | Wilfried Bony | Roberto Soldado |
| 14 | Gabriel Agbonlahor | 22 | Rickie Lambert | Alvaro Negredo | Rickie Lambert | Samuel Eto'o |
| 15 | Samuel Eto'o | 19 | Darren Bent | Ricky van Wolfswinkel | Andreas Weimann | Marouane Chamakh |
| 16 | Edin Dzeko | 17 | Gabriel Agbonlahor | Jay Rodriguez | Gabriel Agbonlahor | Wilfried Bony |
| 17 | Fernando Torres | 16 | Fraizer Campbell | Darren Bent | Papiss Cisse | Rickie Lambert |
| 18 | Darren Bent | 14 | Samuel Eto'o | Marko Arnautovic | Dimitar Berbatov | Darren Bent |
| 19 | Danny Welbeck | 11 | Dimitar Berbatov | Dwight Gayle | Fraizer Campbell | Nicika Jelavic |
| 20 | Fraizer Campbell | 7 | Edin Dzeko | Fraizer Campbell | Darren Bent | Luis Suarez |
MIDFIELDERS
| # | OVERALL | PTS | LAIRD | MOSINSKI | PITNER | RADUNE |
| 1 | Mesut Ozil | 79 | Mesut Ozil | Yaya Toure | Mesut Ozil | Mesut Ozil |
| 2 | Oscar | 68 | Eden Hazard | Mesut Ozil | Oscar | Aaron Ramsey |
| 3 | Yaya Toure | 65 | Oscar | Oscar | Aaron Ramsey | Andros Townsend |
| 4 | Aaron Ramsey | 64 | Yaya Toure | Paulinho | Eden Hazard | David Silva |
| 5 | Michu | 62 | Michu | Ross Barkley | Yaya Toure | Moussa Dembele |
| 6 | Eden Hazard | 57 | Aaron Ramsey | Michu | Michu | Michu |
| 7 | Paulinho | 45 | Paulinho | Frank Lampard | David Silva | Fabian Delph |
| 8 | Steven Gerrard | 43 | Marouane Fellaini | Emanuele Giaccherini | Andros Townsend | Oscar |
| 9 | David Silva | 42 | Frank Lampard | Aaron Ramsey | Steven Gerrard | Yaya Toure |
| 10 | Andros Townsend | 42 | Hatem Ben Arfa | Eden Hazard | Santi Cazorla | Steven Gerrard |
| 11 | Frank Lampard | 34 | Steven Gerrard | Steven Gerrard | Paulinho | Eden Hazard |
| 12 | Ross Barkley | 30 | David Silva | Hatem Ben Arfa | Hatem Ben Arfa | Adam Lallana |
| 13 | Hatem Ben Arfa | 29 | Santi Cazorla | Theo Walcott | Frank Lampard | Adnan Januzaj |
| 14 | Santi Cazorla | 19 | Ross Barkley | Gylfi Sigurdsson | Ross Barkley | Theo Walcott |
| 15 | Theo Walcott | 14 | Andros Townsend | Ravel Morrison | Theo Walcott | Fernandinho |
| 16 | Marouane Fellaini | 13 | Yohan Cabaye | Andros Townsend | Morgan Amalfitano | Mark Noble |
| 17 | Emanuele Giaccherini | 13 | Ramires | Jonjo Shelvey | Kevin Mirallas | Paulinho |
| T18 | Adnan Januzaj | 9 | Victor Moses | Morgan Amalfitano | Ramires | Gareth Barry |
| T18 | Morgan Amalfitano | 9 | Ravel Morrison | David Silva | Adam Lallana | Michael Carrick |
| 20 | Ravel Morrison | 8 | Adnan Januzaj | Mohamed Diame | Samir Nasri | Morgan Amalfitano |
DEFENSEMEN
| # | OVERALL | PTS | LAIRD | MOSINSKI | PITNER | RADUNE |
| 1 | Leighton Baines | 78 | Leighton Baines | Leighton Baines | Leighton Baines | Glen Johnson |
| 2 | Branislav Ivanovic | 71 | Branislav Ivanovic | Branislav Ivanovic | Branislav Ivanovic | Curtis Davies |
| 3 | Pablo Zabaleta | 56 | Kyle Walker | Daniel Agger | Jan Vertonghen | Leighton Baines |
| 4 | Jan Vertonghen | 55 | Jan Vertonghen | Pablo Zabaleta | John Terry | Jan Vertonghen |
| 5 | Kyle Walker | 47 | Pablo Zabaleta | Kieran Gibbs | Seamus Coleman | Sylvan Distin |
| 6 | Seamus Coleman | 42 | Seamus Coleman | David Luiz | Kyle Walker | Danny Rose |
| 7 | David Luiz | 42 | Per Mertesacker | Kyle Walker | David Luiz | Branislav Ivanovic |
| 8 | Glen Johnson | 41 | David Luiz | Jose Fonte | Dejan Lovren | Martin Skrtel |
| 9 | Patrice Evra | 35 | Patrice Evra | John Terry | Jose Enrique | Pablo Zabaleta |
| 10 | John Terry | 33 | Jose Fonte | Seamus Coleman | Pablo Zabaleta | Patrice Evra |
| 11 | Jose Enrique | 30 | Phil Jagielka | Jose Enrique | Glen Johnson | Ben Davies |
| 12 | Dejan Lovren | 29 | Dejan Lovren | Patrice Evra | Per Mertesacker | Chico |
| 13 | Jose Fonte | 28 | Jose Fonte | Aleksander Kolarov | Gareth McAuley | Jonas Olsson |
| 14 | Danny Rose | 27 | Glen Johnson | Dejan Lovren | Phil Jagielka | Nemanja Vidic |
| T15 | Per Mertesacker | 23 | Danny Rose | Danny Rose | Chico | Robert Huth |
| T15 | Daniel Agger | 23 | Gareth McAuley | Robert Huth | Daniel Agger | Gary Cahill |
| 17 | Curtis Davies | 19 | John Terry | Glen Johnson | Jose Fonte | Ashley Williams |
| 18 | Phil Jagielka | 17 | Vincent Kompany | Jan Vertonghen | Patrice Evra | Michael Dawson |
| 19 | Kieran Gibbs | 16 | Gary Cahill | Guy Demel | Matija Nastastic | Aleksander Kolarov |
| T19 | Sylvan Distin | 16 | Ryan Shawcross | Gary Cahill | Erik Pieters | Phil Jones |
GOALKEEPERS
| # | OVERALL | PTS | LAIRD | MOSINSKI | PITNER | RADUNE |
| 1 | Simon Mignolet | 39 | Petr Cech | Simon Mignolet | Simon Mignolet | Simon Mignolet |
| 2 | Petr Cech | 33 | Simon Mignolet | Hugo Lloris | Petr Cech | Brad Guzan |
| 3 | Hugo Lloris | 28 | Joe Hart | Petr Cech | Asmir Begovic | Artur Boruc |
| 4 | Artur Boruc | 25 | Artur Boruc | Joe Hart | Hugo Lloris | Hugo Lloris |
| 5 | Joe Hart | 21 | Wojciech Szczesny | David de Gea | Petr Cech | Petr Cech |
| T6 | Wojciech Szczesny | 16 | Hugo Lloris | Artur Boruc | Artur Boruc | Asmir Begovic |
| T6 | Asmir Begovic | 16 | David de Gea | Tim Howard | Tim Howard | Wojciech Szczesny |
| 8 | David de Gea | 13 | Asmir Begovic | Wojciech Szczesny | Petr Cech | Jussi Jaaskelainen |
| 9 | Tim Howard | 10 | Jussi Jaaskelainen | Jussi Jaaskelainen | Jussi Jaaskelainen | David de Gea |
| 10 | Jussi Jaaskelainen | 9 | Tim Howard | Maarten Stekelenburg | David de Gea | Tim Howard |
